Professional liability insurance (PLI), also referred to as errors and omissions (E&O) insurance, protects professionals against negligence (duty, breach, and damages are elements of negligence), mistakes, and failures to meet industry standards of care. PLI policies provide coverage for legal defense costs and damages, also referred to as indemnity. However, coverage is shaped and differentiated by an expanding array of exclusions, combined limits, deductibles, and more narrowly defined covered perils.
Policy limits vary among perils and carriers. For example, a per-occurrence limit caps coverage at a maximum amount for each specific incident. The aggregate limit caps total claims during the policy period, typically one year. A combined limit aggregates various covered perils, which may or may not have their own respective sub-limits. For instance, a carrier may cover medical records subpoenas, depositions, and trial testimony in any combination, but the total combined coverage may be capped at $35,000. Legal fees may or may not be outside (in excess of) policy limits, making this an important factor when selecting coverage.
Within the professional liability insurance sector, claims have been increasing in severity, driven in part by rising legal fees due to inflationary labor costs. According to Nursing Malpractice Insurance, counselor claims in 2020 averaged $157,492. By 2024, 49.4% of medical professional liability premiums showed a sharp upward trend. Nuclear jury verdicts and judgments have been particularly severe in negligence cases involving invasive therapies. Additionally, claims outcomes vary significantly by state and jurisdiction. While social workers are typically not covered for invasive therapy exposures, they remain vulnerable to high-damage claims across a wide range of allegations. Plaintiffs often include as many allegations as possible to inflate claims and establish a higher starting point for pre-trial negotiations.
According to the Counselor Professional Liability Exposure Claim Report (3rd Edition) from CNA Insurance, the average counselor malpractice claim is $157,492, consistent with the earlier statistic. The most severe allegations involve sexual misconduct and inappropriate non-sexual relationships (such as bartering, socializing, or boundary violations). Improper documentation—including repetitive or AI-generated notes—remains a frequent and serious issue. High-cost claims often stem from “evaluation, assessment, and interpretation,” particularly in child custody, marital dispute, and divorce cases, with average incurred losses of $460,671. Telehealth-related behavioral health claims are also rising sharply in severity, averaging $317,511 in incurred losses.
Common Lawsuit Allegations
Boundary Issues:
Inappropriate relationships or sexual misconduct.
Documentation Errors:
Inadequate or inconsistent notes, weak documentation practices, and errors related to informed consent.
Confidentiality Breaches:
Improper or careless release of client records. Social workers may face first-party risk (e.g., misdirected faxes) or liability under 45 CFR Part 160 (HIPAA/HITECH) when third parties, such as movers or network providers, expose protected health information.
Clinical Issues:
Failure to treat, improper treatment, or failure to appropriately manage high-risk clients, including those with suicidal ideation. These areas are particularly vulnerable to broad and aggressive legal claims. Allegations related to suicide risk management often involve detailed clinical standards and are frequently associated with high-severity losses. Any deviation from established standards may result in highly defensible claims with damages that can exceed policy limits, potentially exposing the social worker to significant personal financial risk.
We recommend mitigating risk through ongoing clinical training and continuing education in these and other critical areas.
To enroll in professional liability insurance, click here. For more information click here.
Free On Demand Course
From Preferra Learn
Field Placement Done Right
Recorded January 8, 2026
This webinar aims to provide school personnel with critical information to develop and monitor the safeguards needed to mitigate potential risks associated with field placement activities.
(90 minutes)
Sexual Misconduct and Boundary Violations
We recognize that the social work profession is a noble one, founded on service, integrity, and clinical expertise. It is also stressful and becoming increasingly dangerous. Thank you for what you do. Liability insurance carriers are experiencing an increasing number...
When Should a Social Worker Break Client Confidentiality?
Following the social work Code of Ethics, HIPAA guidelines and state and federal laws is central to effective and responsible practice. But what if a client exhibits alarming or potentially violent behavior? As social workers, you should always respect client...
What To Do When Your Client Threatens To Harm Themselves or Others
Social workers enter the field to protect and support vulnerable populations. But what happens when a client threatens to harm themselves or others? In these moments, social workers must know and follow the code of ethics, confidentiality laws and HIPAA obligations,...